Medical students play a crucial role in healthcare, learning hands-on skills while working alongside experienced doctors. One of the most debated topics in medical education is whether medical students should be on call. Being on call means being available for emergencies, patient care, and overnight shifts.
In this article, we will explore the benefits, challenges, and expectations for medical students who are on call.
What Does “On Call” Mean for Medical Students?
Being “on call” means that a medical student is assigned to work outside of regular hours, often staying overnight in the hospital. This experience helps students gain practical exposure to emergency situations, surgeries, and patient care under supervision. Depending on the hospital or medical school, students may be expected to respond to pages, assist doctors, and observe critical procedures. The frequency and nature of on-call shifts vary by institution and specialty.
Pros of Medical Students Being On Call:
1. Hands-On Learning Experience
On-call shifts provide real-world exposure that textbooks and lectures cannot match. Medical students witness urgent cases, see different medical conditions, and learn how to manage them. This direct experience helps students develop clinical reasoning and decision-making skills.
2. Improved Clinical Skills
During on-call shifts, students practice essential skills like taking patient histories, performing physical exams, and assisting in procedures. This hands-on practice builds confidence and competence, making them better prepared for residency and future practice.
3. Better Understanding of Medical Specialties
Being on call exposes students to different medical specialties, helping them decide on their future careers. They observe how different teams work, what each specialty entails, and the level of patient interaction required in various fields.
4. Strengthens Resilience and Adaptability
The unpredictable nature of on-call shifts helps students develop problem-solving skills, adaptability, and the ability to work under pressure—qualities essential for a future doctor. Students learn to manage stress and prioritize tasks efficiently.
5. Networking and Mentorship
On-call shifts allow students to interact with senior doctors, residents, and specialists. These connections can be valuable for mentorship, learning, and future career opportunities. Observing and working with different professionals also helps students understand the collaborative nature of healthcare.
6. Exposure to Rare Cases
During overnight and emergency shifts, students may encounter rare or complex medical cases that they would not typically see during regular hours. This enhances their knowledge and clinical experience.
Cons of Medical Students Being On Call:
1. Physical and Mental Exhaustion
Long hours and overnight shifts can be exhausting. Lack of sleep and high-stress situations can lead to burnout, affecting both learning and personal well-being. This fatigue can impact cognitive function and decision-making.
2. Limited Decision-Making Power
Medical students are still learning and do not have the authority to make medical decisions independently. While they observe and assist, their contributions may be limited, which can sometimes make them feel undervalued or unchallenged.
3. Impact on Academic Performance
Being on call can reduce the time available for studying. Some students may struggle to balance clinical duties with their coursework and exams. Institutions should ensure that on-call duties do not interfere with academic performance.
4. Unpaid Workload
Medical students are not paid for on-call shifts, yet they put in long hours and handle demanding tasks. This can feel unfair, especially when combined with the financial strain of medical school. The lack of financial compensation raises ethical questions about unpaid labor in medical training.
5. Emotional Stress
Seeing critically ill patients, trauma cases, and high-pressure situations can be emotionally challenging, especially for students who are new to clinical settings. They may experience emotional fatigue or moral distress when dealing with difficult cases.
6. Disruptions to Personal Life
On-call duties can interfere with a student’s personal life, limiting their ability to maintain social relationships, hobbies, and self-care routines. Maintaining work-life balance can be difficult.
Also Read: Can Medical Assistant Use Steri Strips On Wounds – What You Need To Know!
What to Expect as a Medical Student on Call?
If you are required to be on call as a medical student, here’s what you should prepare for:
- Long Hours: Expect shifts that can last 12–24 hours, including overnight stays.
- Varied Responsibilities: You may assist in procedures, take patient histories, observe surgeries, and respond to emergency cases.
- Sleep Deprivation: Be ready for minimal rest, as hospitals are busy around the clock.
- Teamwork: You will work closely with doctors, nurses, and residents.
- Unexpected Challenges: Each shift is unpredictable, requiring quick learning and adaptability.
- Documentation Duties: You may be responsible for writing patient notes and recording medical histories.
- Self-Care Strategies: Eating well, staying hydrated, and taking breaks when possible will help manage fatigue and stress.
Should Medical Students Be On Call? The Final Verdict?’
There is no one-size-fits-all answer. Some believe that being on call is essential for gaining real-world experience, while others argue it places unnecessary stress on students. The best approach may be a balanced one—allowing students to participate in on-call shifts while ensuring they have enough rest and study time. Institutions should also provide adequate support, including mental health resources and clear guidelines on work expectations.
FAQ’s
1. Are medical students required to be on call?
It depends on the medical school and hospital policies. Some programs require students to take on-call shifts, while others do not.
2. Do medical students get paid for being on call?
No, medical students typically do not receive payment for on-call shifts since they are still in training.
3. How do medical students handle sleep deprivation during on-call shifts?
Many students take short naps when possible, stay hydrated, and use caffeine in moderation to stay alert. Managing time effectively and prioritizing rest after shifts is crucial.
4. Can medical students refuse to be on call?
In most cases, students cannot refuse if on-call duty is part of their curriculum. However, if there are concerns about well-being, they can discuss them with faculty or supervisors.
5. What should a medical student bring for an on-call shift?
Essential items include a stethoscope, notebook, snacks, water, comfortable shoes, and a phone charger. Some students also bring a small pillow or blanket for short rest periods.
6. How can medical students make the most of on-call shifts?
Being proactive, asking questions, and actively participating in patient care can make on-call shifts more educational and rewarding.
7. How often are medical students on call?
The frequency of on-call shifts depends on the medical school and the rotation. Some students may be on call once a week, while others may have shifts less frequently.
Conclusion:
While being on call can be challenging, it provides invaluable hands-on experience for medical students. The decision on whether students should be on call should balance learning opportunities with student well-being. With proper support, time management, and resilience, on-call shifts can be a valuable part of medical training.
Leave a Reply